Portland City Hall hasn't been spared the liveliness that's characterized the other electoral choices we face next week. Erik Sten's resignation means that four seats are on the ballot: a new mayor, two new commissioners, and Randy Leonard's re-election bid.
Taking these from easiest to hardest: first, Portland voters should re-elect Commissioner Leonard over his two challengers. The council works best when its members bring a variety of views and experiences. Five Commissioners Leonard would be too many, but zero is too few. His challengers, who didn't bother to file a statement in the Voter's Pamphlet, haven't made a case for replacing him.
Next, for seat no. 2, voters have an easy choice in selecting Nick Fish over the four other candidates. Jim Middaugh is an engaging fellow who's worked in City Hall for the last several years, and would be a fine addition to the council if Mr. Fish were not in the race, but it's Mr. Fish's turn to have a chance to put his energy and creativity to work in City Hall. (Speculate on who would be running for mayor today if he had defeated Sam Adams in 2004.)
Six candidates, all credible, want seat no. 1. Some appeal to specific groups: for example, unionists may vote for Mike Fahey, and neighborhood activists for Amanda Fritz. I'm also impressed by Charles Lewis's "back to basics" campaign platform, though experience suggests that those platforms don't often survive an official's first term in office. I have nothing negative about any of the candidates. I recommend that voters without a strong reason to prefer for one candidate over another vote for Jeff Bissonnette, whose background is with the Citizens' Utility Board. The City Council missed an easy one when they dithered over whether to acquire Portland General Electric or its assets after Enron went under, and got mired in internecine fighting with other local governments over how to run PGE after a purchase. On the off chance that the city gets a similar chance, I'd like to see Mr. Bissonnette on the council.
What about the center chair? Sam Adams had the election wrapped up, until Mr. Dozono showed up to make this a contest. I like Mr. Adams's energy. I don't like how he handles land use issues, in particular the City's schizophrenia over big-box retail that allows one big box, Ikea, into an industrial area but keeps another, Wal-Mart, out of retail zones. On such things the government is supposed to be a referee and not a power forward. Mr. Dozono makes a good case for why Mr. Adams should not become the mayor (let's not even mention the Sauvie Island bridge fiasco), but he's less compelling about why voters should elect him instead.
The main reason, at this time, for electing Mr. Dozono is similar to my reason for supporting Commissioner Leonard. In addition to his long record of civic service, Mr. Dozono has owned and operated a business in downtown Portland for many years. As the city piles project after project into downtown, it often overlooks -- ignores outright -- how those projects encourage downtown businesses to pack up and move somewhere else. The City needs a downtown businessperson on the council. I recommend voting for Mr. Dozono.
Recent Comments